Is it Better to Remove Excess HSA Contribution or Leave it Alone?

When it comes to managing your health savings account (HSA), one common question that arises is whether it is better to remove excess contributions or leave them be. Let's explore the options and factors to consider to make an informed decision.

If you have contributed more to your HSA than the allowable limit set by the IRS for the year, you have made an excess contribution. Here are some points to consider when deciding what to do with the excess:

• Removing Excess Contributions:
• Prevents Penalties: Removing the excess contributions before the tax filing deadline helps you avoid penalties imposed by the IRS.
• Adjusting Tax Liability: By removing the excess amount, you can adjust your taxable income for the year.
• Leaving Excess Contributions:
• Future Use: You can choose to leave the excess funds in your HSA for future healthcare expenses.
• Investment Opportunities: If your HSA offers investment options, leaving the excess amount to grow can be beneficial in the long run.

Ultimately, whether to remove excess HSA contributions or leave them alone depends on your financial situation and healthcare needs. Consulting with a financial advisor can help you make the best decision based on your individual circumstances.




Deciding whether to remove excess contributions from your health savings account (HSA) can be a challenging dilemma. If you find yourself in a situation where you've contributed more than the IRS allows, you have a couple of viable options to consider.

Removing Excess Contributions:

• Avoiding IRS Penalties: Acting promptly to withdraw the excess contributions before the tax deadline is essential, as it ensures you avoid potential penalties that the IRS may impose for over-contributing.
• Revising Tax Liability: Taking out the excess funds also permits you to amend your taxable income for the year, providing the chance to reduce your overall tax burden.

Leaving Excess Contributions:

• Healthcare Saving for the Future: If you opt to leave the excess contributions, those funds can remain accessible for future medical expenses, giving you a financial cushion.
• Potential Growth Through Investments: Many HSAs allow you to invest, meaning that if you leave your excess contributions, they could yield returns and help grow your savings in the long run.

Ultimately, the choice of whether to withdraw or retain excess contributions in your HSA revolves around your personal financial scenario and healthcare needs. Speaking with a financial advisor could help tailor the decision to best suit your future plans.